Why Building a Smaller, More Engaged Email List Is Better for Everyone
The competitive pressure to grow your list as fast as possible is one of the most counterproductive things in marketing. Here is why smaller email list is smarter.
There is a number that looms large in email marketing culture: the number of subscribers on your list. Marketers talk about hitting 10,000, or 100,000 subscribers as milestones in the same way some people talk about follower counts on social media. The assumption being that the bigger the number, the more successful you are. Except that is not really how it works…
Why big lists are often worse lists
When the goal is “growth at all costs”, the shortcuts start to appear. Buying contacts, reluctance to cleanse lists. Adding people who enquired years ago. Importing lists from events, from LinkedIn. The result is a list full of people who do not particularly want to hear from you.
Low open rates signal to email providers like Gmail and Outlook that your content is not valuable. Too many spam complaints and your emails start going into junk. A bloated list of disengaged contacts actively damages the performance of your emails to the people who do want to hear from you.
The best thing that can happen is an unsubscribe - it’s way better to have a smaller list of engaged people, than a big recipient list with a low open rate. Read that sentence again!
The business case for a smaller, cleaner list
A list of 500 people who genuinely look forward to your emails will always outperform a list of 5,000 who vaguely remember signing up two years ago. Higher open rates, better deliverability, more clicks, more conversions. Every email marketing metric improves when your list is made up of people who actually want to be there.
What ethical list-building actually looks like
• Genuine value exchange. Give people a real reason to sign up. Something specific and genuinely useful: a guide, a resource, a regular insight they cannot get elsewhere.
• Clear expectations. Tell people what they are signing up for, how often you will email them, and what kind of content to expect. Then deliver exactly that.
• Regular list hygiene. Remove inactive subscribers periodically. It improves email performance and your GDPR compliance.
• Double opt-in. Ask new subscribers to confirm their signup. It reduces spam signups and gives you a cleaner consent record.
• An easy, visible unsubscribe. If people can leave easily, the ones who stay actually want to be there.
Our take
A list of 500 engaged subscribers who trust you, open your emails, and buy from you is a genuine business asset. A list of thousands of people who can barely remember signing up is a liability, legally and commercially. We recommend you build your email list for quality and the positive numbers will follow.
Some of our favourite email newsletters
1. The Do Lectures - A curated list of interesting and curious stuff from around the web
2. The School of Life - Wellbeing, emotional intelligence and philosophy
3. Brene Brown - The latest insights from her incredible research
4. The Know - Positive news and impact from around the world
5. Adam Grant - Monthly writing about workplace psychology